Unspeakable by Sandra Brown bears all the hallmarks of a classic romantic suspense; an escaped convict, a haunted drifter, and a woman forced to fight for her life and her son’s future. But somehow, despite its atmospheric setup and high stakes, it never quite delivers the emotional punch I have come to expect from Sandra Brown as one of my favorite and go-to authors.

The story unfolds in Blewer County, Texas, where Carl Herbold, a convicted murderer and psychopath, breaks out of prison and begins a bloody journey home. At the same time, Anna Corbett, a deaf widow raising her young son on her father-in-law’s ranch, takes in Jack Sawyer, a mysterious drifter whose arrival coincides a little too neatly with the prison break. Jack is a man of few words and even fewer explanations, his past hinted at in fragments that suggest ties to both the escaped convicts and a twenty-year-old murder that still haunts the local sheriff.

Anna, meanwhile, is a character who could have been unforgettable. Her deafness gives her a distinctive presence, her world is drawn in sensory detail rather than sound, and the way she navigates both isolation and strength is portrayed with care. Yet, for all the potential in her story, the connection between her and Jack never deepens into the kind of visceral, magnetic bond that defines Sandra Brown’s best work. This is where the magic in characterization happens in her novels, where you see layers to the protagonists that come through in moments of stark revelations and deep passion that was missing from the story. Their interactions are too few, too fleeting, and too understated to build the tension or intimacy that her novels usually thrive on.

The suspense arc dominates the narrative. Brown skillfully crafts a grim picture of depravity through Carl and his brother Cecil, two men bound by blood and violence, and the side characters, particularly the aging and retired sheriff Ezzy, which adds emotional weight to the long-buried secrets that drive the story. Yet, by the final stretch, the violence and the darkness begin to overwhelm rather than serve the plot. The Herbold brothers are monstrous, but in a way that starts to feel senseless; they exist as embodiments of evil rather than as complex villains with understandable motives, and this flattening of their menace dilutes the impact.

Honestly, this was a disappointing Sandra Brown novel. While the villains were horrific, and the tone undeniably dark – two things that I actually love in romantic suspense, it all seemed strangely hollow when the dust settled. Not that one expects logic from criminals of this caliber, but there was little psychological nuance or purpose behind their actions.

Writing romantic suspense, as the genre indicates, is a balancing act. If you fail on one and over-deliver on the other, it is a failed attempt at best. This one seemed to fizzle on both counts, and that was what disappointed me the most. The romance fell flat beyond a few moments that sizzled and fizzled out. Normally, her books pulse with chemistry, the kind that builds quietly until it’s unbearable. Though there were flashes of poignancy and moments that reminded me of why I admire Brown’s storytelling, this one simply didn’t have the spark.

Recommended for: readers who enjoy dark, violent thrillers with a faint thread of romance and an eerie rural setting.

Final Verdict: Unspeakable is bleak, brutal, and atmospheric, but its heart never quite beats. A rare miss from Sandra Brown.

Purchase Links: Amazon | B&N | Kobo | eBooks | Apple