Fall from India Place was one of those books I went into with a lot of emotional investment. Hannah Nichols has been quietly present since the beginning of the On Dublin Street series, and she always felt like the most relatable of the lot. The bookish, thoughtful friend and the one who listened more than she spoke. This installment finally places her at the center, revisiting a past heartbreak that has shaped far more of her adult life than anyone around her realizes.

Hannah’s story revolves around her unresolved connection with Marco D’Alessandro, the only man she has ever loved and the one who walked away after a single, life-altering night years earlier. When fate brings them back together, the pull between them is immediate, but so is the weight of everything left unsaid. Marco wants redemption and a future. Hannah wants safety, control, and certainty after years of quietly surviving something she never allowed herself to fully confront.

Hannah’s emotional journey is the most compelling part of the book. Her fears do not stem only from Marco’s disappearance, but from a deeply buried trauma that reshaped her sense of self, her body, and her relationship with vulnerability. Watching her navigate those fears through her internal monologue is heartbreaking at times, and it explains why she keeps people at arm’s length even when she longs for connection. Marco, on the other hand, remains more elusive. Seen only through Hannah’s eyes, he often feels like an idea rather than a fully realized presence, which made it difficult for me to truly invest in him as her partner.

Where the book struggled for me was in the emotional balance between the two leads. The chemistry that should have been explosive felt muted for much of the story, only truly coming alive in the latter third. By then, the groundwork had already felt uneven. Hannah’s healing journey seemed too complex and deeply rooted to be resolved solely through romance, and at times I found myself wishing the story had allowed more space for her to seek healing beyond the relationship itself. Given that Marco was this figment that materialized every now and then, I saw that Cole, who was always with Hannah through every single aspect of her life, was more of a partner to her than Marco ever felt like. But alas, the two had zero chemistry to gel it all together.

That said, the writing is still undeniably strong, and Samantha Young handles emotional introspection with care. Hannah’s pain feels real, her fears believable, and her hesitations grounded in lived experience. I simply wanted more depth and perspective from Marco, perhaps even his own voice, to bridge the emotional gap between them.

Recommended for: Readers invested in the On Dublin Street series, especially those who value character-driven stories and emotional realism over high heat or fast-paced romance.

Final Verdict: A poignant but uneven installment that gives Hannah a long-awaited voice, even if the romance itself never fully reaches the emotional heights of the earlier books in the series.

Favorite Quotes

“Hannah.” His voice was thick as his eyes began to burn again.
My breathing grew shallow. “We’ve always been honest with each other, right?”
He gave a slight shake of his head. “I can’t.”
“Why?”
“I can’t . . . I can’t tell you I don’t want you.” His eyes studied my face before moving slowly down my body, and everywhere his gaze touched I came alive.
I’d never done much more than kiss a boy, not because I wasn’t ready to explore sex, but because I didn’t want to explore sex with anyone but Marco. I’d heard Ellie, Joss, Jo, and Liv’s crappy losing-their-virginity stories and I’d promised myself that the moment I let someone truly inside me, I’d make sure that someone was someone I loved.
And I loved Marco.
I’d been in love with him since the day he rescued me when I was fourteen years old.

“When we were kids, I was in love with you.”
Surprise, gratification, relief, sheer joy . . . it all moved through me as my eyes widened at his abrupt confession.
“That never went away, Hannah.” He rested his forehead against mine. “And now that I know you again, I’m even more in love with you.”

Purchase Links: Amazon | B&N | Kobo | eBooks | Apple