After the emotional whiplash of Fall from India Place, I went into Echoes of Scotland Street with cautious optimism. Cole Walker had been a steady presence throughout the series, and after seeing him repeatedly through Hannah’s eyes, I was more than ready for his story. Expectations were admittedly high, perhaps unfairly so, but this was meant to be a return to form after a weaker installment. Unfortunately, this book was even weaker than its predecessor.

The story opens with a formative encounter between Cole and Shannon as teenagers, a moment meant to anchor their future connection. Years later, they meet again under very different circumstances, with Shannon emotionally bruised and determined to avoid the exact type of man Cole appears to be. Cole, on the other hand, is instantly all in. He is devoted, patient, and earnest from the start, convinced that Shannon is worth the effort.

Shannon’s emotional baggage is substantial, and while her trauma is understandable, it often dominates the narrative to the point of stagnation. Her resistance feels less like guarded vulnerability and more like an immovable wall. Cole’s pursuit, while well intentioned, occasionally crosses into uncomfortable territory, especially given how clearly she communicates her reluctance early on. When he finally pulls back, it is the result of words that Shannon finally blurts out hurting Cole and bringing forth his own trauma.

What disappointed me most was the complete lack of spark once they do come together. Cole is kind, steady, and emotionally available, but he is also safe to the point of dullness. There is very little edge, very little heat, and almost no sense of danger or urgency. Compared to earlier heroes in the series, particularly Braden, whose presence was commanding both emotionally and physically, Cole simply fades into the background. A gentleman can still be fierce. Here, that balance never materializes.

Shannon, as a heroine, was difficult to connect with despite her traumatic past. Understanding her pain did not translate into liking her, and even in moments where the story asked for emotional release, I felt strangely detached. The romantic arc relied heavily on reassurance from secondary characters rather than organic growth between the leads. Even the sexual chemistry, once a hallmark of this series, felt muted and oddly restrained. And I skipped huge chunks of the book towards the finish line.

Ultimately, this felt like a story that relied too heavily on intention rather than execution. The emotional groundwork was there, but the delivery failed to be satisfactory. Given the rave reviews this installment however received from longtime fans of the series, I maybe an outlier in my opinion. However, for readers who crave intensity, angst, and visceral connection that the earlier three books in the series provided, it may fall particularly flat.

Recommended for: Readers who enjoy gentle, emotionally safe romances with minimal conflict and a patient, steady hero.

Final Verdict: Echoes of Scotland Street is a well meaning installment of the On Dublin Street series that lacked the fire, tension, and emotional grip that once defined the series.

Purchase Links: Amazon | B&N | Kobo | eBooks | Apple