Prescott Lane’s All My Life is a beautifully tender, small-town love story that feels as comforting as a breakfast on a long weekend shared between lifelong friends. It is about lifelong devotion and the kind of love that waits patiently in the background until the world finally catches up. Garrett Hollis, the town’s hardware store owner and devoted single father, has spent his life putting everyone else first, especially his daughter, Mia. And then there is Devlyn Drake, his best friend since childhood, who has quietly loved him for as long as she can remember.

From the outside, they are the perfect little trio; Garrett, Mia, and Devlyn, who owns the local diner and has been a constant presence in both their lives. She is the one who taught him to braid Mia’s hair, who fed them through hard times, and who has always been there, steady as the sunrise, even when the rest of the town had shunned him at first, and Mia’s own mother had forbade her daughter from seeing her friend who ended up with a pregnant teenage girlfriend. But beneath all that friendship simmers a love Devlyn has kept buried for decades. When Garrett begins to see her differently, really see her, the shift is slow, believable, and heartwarming. His journey from denial to awareness is beautifully written, capturing the confusion and awe of a man who realizes too late that love has been within arm’s reach all along.

What I loved most about this story is Devlyn herself. She is unassuming, kind, and deeply selfless, the kind of heroine whose quiet strength speaks louder than any grand gesture. Her bravery in loving Garrett for so long, in taking the risk to reach for what she has always wanted, is what makes this story sing. Garrett, for his part, is the kind of hero you fall for precisely because he does not try to be perfect; he is flawed, loyal, and impossibly endearing as a father. His devotion to Mia is his defining trait, and seeing him balance that love while opening his heart to Devlyn is nothing short of moving.

If there is one thing I wished for, it was a stronger grovel from Garrett, a moment that truly reflected the depth of what Devlyn meant to him. For a man who has been burned before, his emotional evolution sometimes felt a little too easy, his redemption not quite matching the years of quiet devotion she carried for him. But that said, All My Life is not a story of angst so much as one of grace and patience. Devlyn’s forgiveness, her endless capacity to understand, is both her greatest strength and her most poignant vulnerability.

This book could have easily veered into melodrama, but Prescott Lane keeps it grounded. The tone is heartfelt and real, the characters wonderfully lived-in, and the relationship between father and daughter just as powerful as the central romance. Devlyn truly is the heart of this story, the masterpiece that ties it all together.

Recommended for: fans of single-dad romances, small-town love stories, and heroines who love quietly but fiercely.

Final Verdict: All My Life is a tender, heartfelt tale of enduring love and second chances—proof that sometimes the best love stories are the ones that have been right in front of us all along.

Favorite Quotes

She looks up at me and whispers, “I lied to you about something.”
I’ve been lied to enough by women. Sheena took care of that by the time I was eighteen. Devlyn knows that. “What?”
“Scott,” she says, looking down, her skin turning red.
“Devlyn, if you didn’t really break up with him, you are now!”
She looks up, a tight-lipped smile on her face. “I lied to you about why we broke up.”
“You said you guys were all business.”
“That’s true, but there’s more to it.”
“Okay, so what’s the real reason?”
Lightly, she places her hand on my cheek. “He’s not you.”

Purchase Links: Amazon | B&N | Kobo | Apple