Broken Heart Syndrome by Susie Tate is one of those books that blends humor, angst, and a heartfelt romance against the backdrop of a medical setting. The story features Frankie as the main female lead, a shy, reclusive heroine who has carried the scars of a painful past and the humiliating nickname “Frigid Frankie” since her university days. Back then, she and her best friend were quietly infatuated with Reverend Thomas G. Longley, Tom, the charismatic, seemingly easygoing golden boy of medical school. But when he publicly embarrassed her, that crush turned into a wound she carried for years. Ten years later, fate throws them back together when Frankie ends up working under Tom in Cardiology, only to discover that he has become her critical, domineering boss.

Frankie is a heroine who carries so much weight on her shoulders. With a childhood marked by abuse, neglect, and the grief of losing her mother, it is little wonder she struggles with self-esteem. She is self-deprecating, a master at fading into the background, and often doubts her worth in both her personal and professional life. Yet, beneath all that fragility, she is compassionate, fiercely loyal to her patients, and far stronger than she realizes.

Tom, on the other hand, is not the easygoing charmer Frankie once admired. Now, he is sharp, critical, and difficult to please, hiding behind a harsh persona born from his own hurt pride and unresolved feelings. While he initially comes across as a bully, it soon becomes clear that his cruelty is a misguided defense mechanism. Watching him wrestle with his growing feelings for Frankie, while also realizing just how deeply he had misjudged her, was one of the most compelling aspects of the book. His determination to break through Frankie’s defenses, despite her mistrust, made him both frustrating and endearing in equal measure.

Their relationship is marked by misunderstandings, pride, and the ghosts of their past. Frankie struggles to believe that a man like Tom could ever want someone like her, and Tom’s earlier actions, coupled with the meddling of Dylan, who harbored his own unspoken feelings for Frankie, only drive a deeper wedge between them. Add to this Frankie’s history of abuse and the emotional baggage she carries, and what unfolds is a slow, tentative journey toward trust and healing. But the push and pull between them, along with their undeniable chemistry, makes every small victory feel that much more satisfying.

What I loved most about this book was the humor sprinkled in amid the heaviness. Ash and his eccentric habit of quoting proverbs, Lou’s no-nonsense friendship, and even the chaos of hospital life added moments of levity that balanced the emotional intensity. Frankie’s vulnerability was beautifully written, and Tom’s groveling, though subtle compared to more dramatic romances, still managed to deliver.

What disappointed me, however, was the closed-door approach to intimacy. After such a long buildup, I had hoped for more on-page. Frankie’s tendency to push Tom away because of her insecurities also veered into frustrating at times, though it fit her character arc.

Recommended for: readers who enjoy medical romances with emotionally scarred heroines, alpha heroes who have to work hard to redeem themselves, and stories that blend humor, heartache, and hope.

Final Verdict: A poignant and witty romance low on the steam factor but delivers a heartfelt journey of healing, forgiveness, and love.

Favorite Quotes

‘You smell amazing,’ she said, her voice aching with longing. Tom froze and looked up at her face.
‘What?’ he whispered.
‘But then I shouldn’t be surprised,’ she went on, ignoring him. ‘Everything about you is lush, lush, lush.’

Purchase Links: Amazon | B&N | Apple